Incremental Cost, Measurable Savings: Enterprise Green Communities Criteria

December 12th, 2017

Applying comprehensive green methods and materials to affordable housing developments invariably raises two hotly debated questions: 1) How much do these measures cost? and 2)Are these measures cost-effective? In-depth answers to both questions are now available from Enterprise Community Partners. This report shares findings from our evaluation of 27 affordable housing developments across the United States that meet the Enterprise Green Communities Criteria. From a strictly financial standpoint, the projected “lifetime” utility cost savings—averaging $4,851 per dwelling unit discounted to today’s dollars—are sufficient to repay the average $4,524 per-unit cost of complying with the Enterprise Green Communities Criteria. In summary, estimated lifetime savings exceed the initial costs of incorporating the Enterprise Green Communities Criteria into affordable housing. The Criteria offer health, economic and environmental benefits by addressing integrated design, location, site improvements, water conservation, energy efficiency, materials that benefit the environment, healthy living environments, and operations and maintenance of affordable housing. Integrating the required Criteria can also produce substantial increases in residents’ quality of life. Developers of the 27 projects discussed in this report found it financially feasible to meet the Criteria, which go beyond energy and water conservation measures to include requirements that advance quality of life, such as: • Promoting smart growth by choosing sites near public transit and community amenities, while avoiding sprawl, disturbance of wetlands and “leapfrog” development into greenfields. Using healthier materials such as the Carpet and Rug Institute’s Green Label carpets, as well as paints and adhesives with no or low percentages of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). • Ensuring better indoor air quality by directly venting kitchen stoves and bath areas to the outdoors, and using other methods to re-supply fresh air and reduce the potential for moisture infiltration, which could lead to possible mold growth and negative effects on residents’ health. While this report focuses on the cost-effectiveness of meeting the Enterprise Green Communities Criteria, forthcoming reports will examine the Criteria’s impact on carbon reductions and improved health of residents. For example, through our experience with the Enterprise Green Communities Offset Fund, we calculated that, on average, the housing units studied will cut 2 tons of CO2 emissions annually, compared to homes that only meet local building code standards.